On choice, freedom, and learning to trust yourself
As a therapist, I often find myself in a room with a client looking at me with a desperate look in their eyes and, in a pleading voice exclaiming “Just tell me what to do and I’ll do it!”.
I’ve been teaching aspiring therapists for over 15 years. On the very first day of class, I usually ask them: “What does a therapist do?” For graduate psychotherapy students, it seems like an easy enough question. “Listen,” some would say. “Understand,” someone else would respond. However, the most common answer was “Give good advice.”
Just like my students, clients often assume that, as with medical doctors, people go to therapy to get a diagnosis and detailed instructions about what needs to be done. It comes as a surprise (often paired with frustration) that many approaches agree that good therapists are NOT there to give advice1. So no, I am not going to tell them what to do. Instead, I am going to help you figure it out for yourself.
Don’t get me wrong. It is tempting. Have I not been trained for years in active listening, psychodynamics, and diagnosis? Have I not talked to hundreds of clients with similar issues? Don’t I know better? No, I don’t. Shouldn’t I cut to the chase and tell them exactly what to do? After all, they are asking for it, right? No, I shouldn’t.
Let’s explore why.
Every choice is also a letting go.
I am sure that you, just like me, have found yourself struggling to make a choice, wishing for someone to simply hand you a solution. We all have.
For every one thing we select, we renounce hundreds of other possibilities. Choosing a partner means forsaking all others (some even potentially better). Accepting one job offer means saying no to others that might come later; even choosing an ice cream flavor means giving up all the others. Choosing is unsettling precisely because alternatives exist, and there is no way to know with absolute certainty whether we are making the “right” choice. Often, there is no single right answer.
We humans highly value freedom, even to the point of going to war for it. However, like many gifts, it carries a heavy burden. Freedom involves confronting uncertainty, consequences, regret, failure, and disappointment. Although not choosing is itself a choice, postponing or avoiding a decision may give us the illusion that we are keeping our options open, and thus avoiding mistakes. No wonder choosing can feel so daunting.
With so much at stake, we develop ways to try to escape freedom.
Becoming good boys and girls
Interestingly, not choosing is a familiar experience for all of us. When we were children, most choices were made for us. Parents, teachers, religious leaders, etc., told us what to do. They had experience, they knew better (or so we thought), so being obedient made sense. Besides, sometimes being noncompliant came with a heavy price tag: harm, anger, punishment, or isolation. So we learned to behave.
It made sense. It provided safety and relief from anxiety. We paid for security with our freedom. Back then, the bargain paid off. We survived. No wonder that, as we grow up, many of us long for those simpler times.
To make things even more complicated, unconscious motives, shaped by forgotten childhood experiences, push us from below to shrink from deciding, confronting, or speaking out. When we learn that asserting ourselves leads to pain and rejection, we also learn that not deciding keeps us safe. As adults, we keep repeating these learned patterns without realizing that we are trapped by our own past.
Help me!
So we go on living, avoiding decisions, hoping that if we procrastinate long enough, or appear sufficiently helpless or in pain, someone will “rescue” us and make the choice for us.
Sure enough, many find someone willing to do it. Parents gurus, partners, coaches, bosses, or any other authority figures ready to give us their answers.
Still, freedom is an inherent part of who we are, so eventually we may rebel against those figures and claim our freedom… for a little while. Until the next big decision comes along and we begin looking for someone new to relieve our anxiety and assume, once again, the parental role.
Sometimes, after repeating this cycle many times, or when our better selves get tired of our inability to decide, we end up in a therapy office. But bad habits die hard, and even there we try to reproduce those same dynamics, struggling (often unconsciously) to grow up and take charge of our lives. We offer the therapist the same bargain, our freedom for safety.
Just tell me what to do… please.
As I said, this is a common plea. The client may be convinced (and try to convince their therapist) that they truly need someone to rescue them. They may idealize the therapist as a wise person who knows better, transferring to them the same authority figure role. This is understandable; behind these actions there is often real exhaustion, confusion, loneliness or fear.
At this crossroads, therapists who are not careful (or who need to feel useful, loved, clever, etc.) may take on that role and reenact those same patterns, robbing the client of the opportunity to grow up and learn to stand on their own two feet.
In those moments, a good therapist holds unwavering faith in the client and lets them work through that anxiety to realize that they are not helpless; that they can, in fact, come up with their own answers. Ideally, therapists know in their bones that, by providing the right healing environment, clients can find their voice, reclaim their power, and learn to trust themselves. By kindly refusing the bargain, we give clients their freedom back.
So, you’re not going to tell me what to do?
No. A caring therapist resists the client’s pleas or demands for answers (and their corresponding frustration) and encourages them to develop their own capacity to discern.
Even if they use different language, most approaches to psychotherapy agree on the importance of moving from dependency toward maturity.2 Some talk about developing an internal locus of control and the capacity to trust our own experience and judgment. Others advocate becoming aware of our patterns, confronting anxiety, and taking ownership of our lives. Yet the goal is similar: to become adults.
This is hard work. We humans are really good at tricking ourselves. Our motives are often masked by unconscious assumptions, deeply ingrained patterns, contradictory desires, attachment wounds, pre-rational impulses, and false beliefs. A skillful therapist can help clients explore all of this within a safe, judgment-free environment so clients can venture to find their own solutions.
Growing up is a never-ending process
We don’t have to stop growing. That is good news. When we were children, every new development (crawling, walking, learning to ride a bike, doing something by ourselves…) was an accomplishment. Life was (and still is) an adventure. Every step, from the crib to old age, provides new opportunities to learn, master new skills, heal what got skewed along the way, and keep maturing into more fully realized adults.
It has been suggested that becoming a fully realized human being involves a series of interrelated dimensions.3 We need to grow up (developmental maturation), clean up (addressing our shadow), open up (expanding our capacities), show up (taking ownership), and wake up (spiritual awakening).
Learning to make choices and take responsibility for our lives is not the only step, but perhaps one of the first on the path to becoming who we really are.
Learning to trust your own answers
If you find yourself stuck in indecision, repeatedly looking to others for answers, or struggling to trust your own judgment, therapy can provide a place to understand what gets in the way and find your own way forward. You’re welcome to learn more about working together.
- Of course there are exceptions to this. For example, when a client is in crisis. Likewise, some approaches are less rigid about this than others. ↩︎
- This is particularly significant. Therapeutic approaches rarely agree about anything. ↩︎
- See Ken Wilber’s “Finding Radical Wholeness” ↩︎